20260327_opposition-brief_df_response-to-motion-for-limited-discovery-and-index.md

Document

Run details

Annotations by FOLIO branch

Triples (115 FOLIO-linked, 32 unlinked)

Each triple is one Subject → Predicate → Object assertion extracted from a sentence. FOLIO-linked slots show the matched ontology concept; unlinked slots show the raw text only.

• the speedy determination of the issue → be of → prime consideration Consideration
  “In such proceedings, 'the speedy determination of the issue is of prime consideration.'”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → seek requested → deposition , Deposition
  “Nevertheless, Plaintiff seeks leave to conduct burdensome discovery, through an expansive 30(b)(6) deposition, as part of a fishing expedition to test the validity of the Defendants' response.”
• this special action U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act concept → present presented sent sent sent presented → a dispute over whether the Defendants , the City of Phoenix and Phoenix the City Defendant City of Birth
  “Importantly, this special action does not present a dispute over whether the Defendants, the City of Phoenix and”
• the ' City ' ) City of Birth concept → withhold → certain categories of documents
  “District Four Councilwoman Laura Pastor (collectively, the 'City') have improperly withheld certain categories of documents.”
• Plaintiff 's motion Plaintiff concept Motion to Pay concept → rest on → unsupported speculation that additional records exist and seeks intrusive discovery that is neither necessary nor consistent with the streamlined nature of special action proceedings Discovery Practice U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act
  “Plaintiff's motion rests on unsupported speculation that additional records exist and seeks intrusive discovery that is neither necessary nor consistent with the streamlined nature of special action proceedings.”
• The City the City individual City of Birth concept → request requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested → # # FACTUAL BACKGROUND FACTUAL BACKGROUND Background Check
  “The City respectfully requests that the Court deny Plaintiff's requested relief. ## FACTUAL BACKGROUND This special action arises from two public records requests submitted by Plaintiff Jeremy Thacker to the City of Phoenix (the 'City') pursuant to Arizona's Public Records Law, A.R.S. § 39-121 et seq. ”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → submit → two requests
  “On September 30, 2023, Plaintiff submitted two requests through the City's centralized public records portal.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → submit On → September 30 , 2023
  “On September 30, 2023, Plaintiff submitted two requests through the City's centralized public records portal.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → submit through → the City 's centralized public records portal Central the City City of Birth Public Records Act Claim
  “On September 30, 2023, Plaintiff submitted two requests through the City's centralized public records portal.”
• The first request Request concept → seek requested → text messages , mobile phone logs , social messaging , and other forms of communication - between members of City Council District Four and certain identified individuals and organizations City Council Document Text City of Birth City Council
  “The first request sought communications-including emails, text messages, mobile phone logs, social messaging, and other forms of communication-between members of City Council District Four and certain identified individuals and organizations.”
• The first request Request concept → seek requested → mobile phone logs , social messaging , and other forms of communication - between members of City Council District Four and certain identified individuals and organizations City Council City of Birth City Council
  “The first request sought communications-including emails, text messages, mobile phone logs, social messaging, and other forms of communication-between members of City Council District Four and certain identified individuals and organizations.”
• The first request Request concept → seek including requested → emails ,
  “The first request sought communications-including emails, text messages, mobile phone logs, social messaging, and other forms of communication-between members of City Council District Four and certain identified individuals and organizations.”
• The second request Request concept → seek requested → similar categories of communications between members of City Council District Four and two additional named individuals - employees in the City 's Planning Department City Council Planning Department the City City of Birth City Council City of Birth
  “The second request sought similar categories of communications between members of City Council District Four and two additional named individuals-employees in the City's Planning Department.”
• City 's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf . 's Public Records Request R004767 - 093023 , attached as Exhibit 1 ; City 's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf . 's Public Records Request R004768 - 093023 , attached as Exhibit 2 ] Confirmation of Receipt of Plf individual City of Birth concept Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation concept Purchase Receipt concept Request concept Public Records Act Claim concept Exhibit concept City of Birth concept Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation concept Purchase Receipt concept Request concept Public Records Act Claim concept Exhibit concept → assign → tracking reference numbers Invoice Reference
  “[City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004767-093023, attached as Exhibit 1; City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004768-093023, attached as Exhibit 2] The City acknowledged receipt of both requests that same day and assigned tracking reference numbers through its public records system.”
• The City the City individual City of Birth concept → assign → tracking reference numbers Invoice Reference
  “[City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004767-093023, attached as Exhibit 1; City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004768-093023, attached as Exhibit 2] The City acknowledged receipt of both requests that same day and assigned tracking reference numbers through its public records system.”
• City 's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf . 's Public Records Request R004767 - 093023 , attached as Exhibit 1 ; City 's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf . 's Public Records Request R004768 - 093023 , attached as Exhibit 2 ] Confirmation of Receipt of Plf individual City of Birth concept Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation concept Purchase Receipt concept Request concept Public Records Act Claim concept Exhibit concept City of Birth concept Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation concept Purchase Receipt concept Request concept Public Records Act Claim concept Exhibit concept → acknowledge authenticated → receipt of both requests Purchase Receipt
  “[City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004767-093023, attached as Exhibit 1; City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004768-093023, attached as Exhibit 2] The City acknowledged receipt of both requests that same day and assigned tracking reference numbers through its public records system.”
• The City the City individual City of Birth concept → acknowledge authenticated → receipt of both requests Purchase Receipt
  “[City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004767-093023, attached as Exhibit 1; City's Confirmation of Receipt of Plf.'s Public Records Request R004768-093023, attached as Exhibit 2] The City acknowledged receipt of both requests that same day and assigned tracking reference numbers through its public records system.”
• Exhibit 2 ] Exhibit concept → process → approximately 11,000 public records requests Request Public Records Act Claim
  “[Exhibit 1; Exhibit 2] The City processes approximately 11,000 public records requests each year-that is more than 211 requests per week on average.”
• The City the City individual City of Birth concept → process → approximately 11,000 public records requests Request Public Records Act Claim
  “[Exhibit 1; Exhibit 2] The City processes approximately 11,000 public records requests each year-that is more than 211 requests per week on average.”
• Exhibit 2 ] Exhibit concept → onboarde → a new employee Employee
  “[ See Exhibit 1; Exhibit 2] In March 2025, the City onboarded a new employee to serve as a Public Records Coordinator.”
• Exhibit 2 ] Exhibit concept → onboarde In → March 2025
  “[ See Exhibit 1; Exhibit 2] In March 2025, the City onboarded a new employee to serve as a Public Records Coordinator.”
• the City the City individual City of Birth concept → onboarde → a new employee Employee
  “[ See Exhibit 1; Exhibit 2] In March 2025, the City onboarded a new employee to serve as a Public Records Coordinator.”
• the City the City individual City of Birth concept → onboarde In → March 2025
  “[ See Exhibit 1; Exhibit 2] In March 2025, the City onboarded a new employee to serve as a Public Records Coordinator.”
• This new employee Employee concept → bring → the headcount of the Public Records Division the Public Records Division Public Records Act Claim
  “This new employee brings the headcount of the Public Records Division to four.”
• The City the City individual City of Birth concept → produce produced approved filed → the records responsive to both of Plaintiff 's requests-431 pages of emails Plaintiff
  “The City has since conducted a reasonably diligent search and produced the records responsive to both of Plaintiff's requests-431 pages of emails and eight pages of text messages.”
• The City the City individual City of Birth concept → conduct Plan and prepare for → a reasonably diligent search Search
  “The City has since conducted a reasonably diligent search and produced the records responsive to both of Plaintiff's requests-431 pages of emails and eight pages of text messages.”
• the City the City individual City of Birth concept → comply with → its obligations under A.R.S. § 39 - 121 et seq § A.R.S. Sequestration
  “Although these records were not provided until after Plaintiff filed this special action, the City has fully complied with its obligations under A.R.S. § 39-121 et seq . ”
• the City 's attorneys the City individual City of Birth concept → cooperate In → fact
  “In fact, the City's attorneys cooperated in good faith with Plaintiff's counsel to make reasonable efforts to locate the records Plaintiff sought by formulating agreed-upon search terms that went well beyond Plaintiff's initial public records requests.”
• the City 's attorneys the City individual City of Birth concept → cooperate in → good faith with Plaintiff 's counsel Counsel Plaintiff
  “In fact, the City's attorneys cooperated in good faith with Plaintiff's counsel to make reasonable efforts to locate the records Plaintiff sought by formulating agreed-upon search terms that went well beyond Plaintiff's initial public records requests.”
• the speedy determination of the issue → be of → prime consideration Consideration
  “Rather, 'the speedy determination of the issue is of prime consideration.'”
• # # A. Information Sought Information Industry concept → be to → Warrant Discovery Warrant Discovery Practice
  “## A. Information Sought is not Relevant or of Sufficient Evidentiary Value to Warrant Discovery. ”
• Plaintiff 's own counsel Counsel individual Plaintiff concept → collaborate with → the City the City City of Birth
  “However, Plaintiff's own counsel collaborated with the City in developing the scope of the second search.”
• Exhibit 3 ] Exhibit concept → undermine → any claim that the search methodology was unreasonably deficient or biased Search
  “[Exhibit 3] That fact significantly undermines any claim that the search methodology was unreasonably deficient or biased. ”
• That fact → undermine → any claim that the search methodology was unreasonably deficient or biased Search
  “[Exhibit 3] That fact significantly undermines any claim that the search methodology was unreasonably deficient or biased. ”
• 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 # # B. Plaintiff 's Evidence Plaintiff concept Evidence concept → demonstrate → Sufficient Need for Discovery Discovery Practice
  “1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 ## B. Plaintiff's Evidence Does Not Demonstrate Sufficient Need for Discovery. ”
• the court in an original special action Court Forum concept U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act concept → ground → its exercise of discretion to issue special orders concerning discovery Discovery Practice
  “'Unless an appropriate showing is made on which the court in an original special action can ground its exercise of discretion to issue special orders concerning discovery, the parties are generally not entitled to discovery.'”
• Plaintiff 's proffered evidence Plaintiff concept Evidence concept → meet → this standard
  “Plaintiff's proffered evidence does not meet this standard.”
• The trial court Trial Court Practice concept Court Forum concept → rule after → a hearing Hearing
  “at 198 ('The trial court, after a hearing, ruled that some of the information had already been furnished to the Recipients and that the remainder of the information sought was not relevant or of sufficient evidentiary value to warrant an order compelling discovery.').”
• Arizona 's public records law Arizona concept Public Records Act Claim concept → apply to applies → documents pertaining to official activities Activities Related to Credit Intermediation Industry
  “Significantly, Arizona's public records law applies only to documents pertaining to official activities.”
• W]e → reject rejected rejected → [ the ] argument 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 that all e - mails generated or maintained on a government - owned computer system Computer Systems Design Services
  “As the Arizona Supreme Court has stated: '[W]e reject [the] argument 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 that all e-mails generated or maintained on a government-owned computer system are automatically public records[;]”
• W]e → reject rejected rejected → mails
  “As the Arizona Supreme Court has stated: '[W]e reject [the] argument 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 that all e-mails generated or maintained on a government-owned computer system are automatically public records[;]”
• - → reflect concerning → the requisite substantial nexus Government Relations
  “[s]ome e-mails will relate solely to personal matters and will not, therefore, reflect the requisite substantial nexus with government activities.'”
• mails → reflect concerning → the requisite substantial nexus Government Relations
  “[s]ome e-mails will relate solely to personal matters and will not, therefore, reflect the requisite substantial nexus with government activities.'”
• - → relate to concerning → personal matters
  “[s]ome e-mails will relate solely to personal matters and will not, therefore, reflect the requisite substantial nexus with government activities.'”
• mails → relate to concerning → personal matters
  “[s]ome e-mails will relate solely to personal matters and will not, therefore, reflect the requisite substantial nexus with government activities.'”
• The City 's retention schedule Retention Schedule individual the City individual City of Birth concept → provide for Communicate → the disposal of such messages
  “The City's retention schedule provides for the disposal of such messages after ninety days.”
• The City 's retention schedule Retention Schedule individual the City individual City of Birth concept → provide after Communicate → ninety days ninety days
  “The City's retention schedule provides for the disposal of such messages after ninety days.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → submit → his request Request
  “[Excerpt from City's Records Retention Schedule, attached as Exhibit 4] Plaintiff submitted his request on September 30, 2023, more than nineteen months after the February 28, 2022 email, meaning that any such messages may have been lawfully destroyed.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → submit on → September 30 , 2023 ,
  “[Excerpt from City's Records Retention Schedule, attached as Exhibit 4] Plaintiff submitted his request on September 30, 2023, more than nineteen months after the February 28, 2022 email, meaning that any such messages may have been lawfully destroyed.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → submit after → the February 28 , 2022 email Email Communication
  “[Excerpt from City's Records Retention Schedule, attached as Exhibit 4] Plaintiff submitted his request on September 30, 2023, more than nineteen months after the February 28, 2022 email, meaning that any such messages may have been lawfully destroyed.”
• The absence of responsive text messages Document Text concept → create concerning → a factual dispute warranting discovery Discovery Practice
  “The absence of responsive text messages is, therefore, entirely consistent with lawful records management practices and does not create a factual dispute warranting discovery. ”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → will → nonexistent documents into existence
  “Critically, Plaintiff cannot simply will nonexistent documents into existence through the forcefulness and repetition of his requests.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → will through → the forcefulness and repetition of his requests
  “Critically, Plaintiff cannot simply will nonexistent documents into existence through the forcefulness and repetition of his requests.”
• # # C. Plaintiff 's Request Plaintiff concept Request concept → be In → Substance
  “## C. Plaintiff's Request Is, In Substance, An Attempt to Conduct 'Discovery on Discovery.' ”
• Arizona 's public records law Arizona concept Public Records Act Claim concept → operate on → an honor system grounded in legal and professional obligations to produce relevant , nonprivileged information Obligation Informational Advertisement Information Industry
  “Much like the discovery process in the civil litigation context, Arizona's public records law operates on an honor system grounded in legal and professional obligations to produce relevant, nonprivileged information, after reasonable inquiry, that is within the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 ## party's possession, custody, and control.”
• the whole discovery system Discovery Practice concept → break into → an endless barrage of motions Motions
  “If second-guessing was the norm, the whole discovery system would break down into an endless barrage of motions based on mistrust about the opponent's production.”
• Counsel 's status as an officer of the court , combined with the possibility of serious sanctions embedded in Rules 11 and 37 and other professional disciplinary measures , Counsel individual Status concept Court Reporter concept Court Forum concept Sanctions concept Rules of Evidence concept Professional Development concept → serve as served served served → a deterrent
  “Counsel's status as an officer of the court, combined with the possibility of serious sanctions embedded in Rules 11 and 37 and other professional disciplinary measures, serve as a deterrent to lawyers from either intentionally or negligently failing to produce information.”
• Counsel 's status as an officer of the court , combined with the possibility of serious sanctions embedded in Rules 11 and 37 and other professional disciplinary measures , Counsel individual Status concept Court Reporter concept Court Forum concept Sanctions concept Rules of Evidence concept Professional Development concept → serve to served served served → lawyers
  “Counsel's status as an officer of the court, combined with the possibility of serious sanctions embedded in Rules 11 and 37 and other professional disciplinary measures, serve as a deterrent to lawyers from either intentionally or negligently failing to produce information.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → seek requested → the functional equivalent of ' discovery upon discovery Discovery Practice Discovery Motion Practice Discovery Practice
  “Here, Plaintiff is seeking the functional equivalent of 'discovery upon discovery.'”
• Plaintiff 's second - guessing here Plaintiff concept → be given → the City 's efforts to work cooperatively with his counsel to conduct a second search for records with agreedupon terms and scope Counsel the City City of Birth Search
  “Plaintiff's second-guessing here is clearly unwarranted given the City's efforts to work cooperatively with his counsel to conduct a second search for records with agreedupon terms and scope.”
• courts Courts concept → permit approved → parties
  “Absent specific and substantial evidence of a material failure, courts do not permit parties to conduct intrusive examinations into collection and review methodologies.”
• the whole discovery system Discovery Practice concept → break into → an endless barrage of motions Motions
  “As LKQ Corp. Court properly acknowledged, if secondguessing was the norm, the whole discovery system would break down into an endless barrage of motions based on mistrust about the opponent's production.”
• This principle → be in → a special action where the procedural framework prioritizes speed and efficiency U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act
  “This principle is particularly compelling in a special action where the procedural framework prioritizes speed and efficiency.”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → request Despite requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested → his purported ' evidence ' of nonresponsiveness being limited to text messages sent to Councilmember Pastor Councilmember Pastor Evidence Document Text
  “Despite his purported 'evidence' of nonresponsiveness being limited to text messages sent to Councilmember Pastor, Plaintiff is requesting to depose a representative of the City on fifteen sweeping categories that span across multiple Public Records requests. ”
• Plaintiff 's request for ' limited ' discovery Plaintiff concept Request concept Discovery Practice concept → be → a misnomer
  “Plaintiff's request for 'limited' discovery is a misnomer, insofar as he seeks, among other things, limitless and City-wide testimony regarding: - Policies and practices regarding records of public business on non-City-issued devices or accounts, including what steps Defendants take (if any) to capture or preserve such communications when they relate to official activity, and how Defendants determined whether such sources were implicated here. - Retention, archiving, and deletion practices relevant to the custodians/systems searched, including any applicable retention schedules or purge cycles for email, text messaging, and collaboration tools during the relevant time period. ”
• Plaintiff 's request for ' limited ' discovery Plaintiff concept Request concept Discovery Practice concept → be among → other things , limitless and City - wide testimony City of Birth Testimonial Evidence
  “Plaintiff's request for 'limited' discovery is a misnomer, insofar as he seeks, among other things, limitless and City-wide testimony regarding: - Policies and practices regarding records of public business on non-City-issued devices or accounts, including what steps Defendants take (if any) to capture or preserve such communications when they relate to official activity, and how Defendants determined whether such sources were implicated here. - Retention, archiving, and deletion practices relevant to the custodians/systems searched, including any applicable retention schedules or purge cycles for email, text messaging, and collaboration tools during the relevant time period. ”
• the City the City individual City of Birth concept → provide Communicate → Plaintiff Plaintiff
  “If the Court deems discovery necessary, the City can affirmatively provide Plaintiff with information regarding efforts to retrieve and produce text messages sent or received by Councilmember Pastor by furnishing sworn declarations from relevant City employees and officials.”
• the City the City individual City of Birth concept → provide with Communicate → information regarding efforts to retrieve and produce text messages sent or received by Councilmember Pastor by furnishing sworn declarations from relevant City employees and officials Councilmember Pastor Information Industry Document Text Declaration City of Birth
  “If the Court deems discovery necessary, the City can affirmatively provide Plaintiff with information regarding efforts to retrieve and produce text messages sent or received by Councilmember Pastor by furnishing sworn declarations from relevant City employees and officials.”
• Plaintiff 's request for an index Plaintiff concept Request concept → lack → legal or evidentiary support
  “Plaintiff's request for an index likewise lacks legal or evidentiary support.”
• A.R.S. § § individual A.R.S. individual → define → agency Agency Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
  “A.R.S. § 41-1001(1) defines 'agency' as: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 any board, commission, department, officer or other administrative unit of this state, including the agency head and one or more members of the agency head or agency employees or other persons directly or indirectly purporting to act on behalf or under the authority of the agency head, whether created under the Constitution of Arizona or by enactment of the legislature.”
• A.R.S. § § individual A.R.S. individual → define including → the agency head and one or more members of the agency head or agency employees or other persons Agency Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
  “A.R.S. § 41-1001(1) defines 'agency' as: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 any board, commission, department, officer or other administrative unit of this state, including the agency head and one or more members of the agency head or agency employees or other persons directly or indirectly purporting to act on behalf or under the authority of the agency head, whether created under the Constitution of Arizona or by enactment of the legislature.”
• Agency Agency individual Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality concept → include includes → a political subdivision of this state Saint Lucia (subdivision of Malta)
  “[ ] Agency does not include a political subdivision of this state . . .”
• the Legislature Legislature individual → make as → a matter of public policy Governmental Policy
  “Thus, as a matter of public policy, the Legislature made a deliberate decision to spare municipalities from the burden of creating an index.”
• This Court Court Forum concept → override Review/analyze → this policy decision
  “This Court should not casually override this policy decision. ”
• such relief → be → # # CONCLUSION Plaintiff has not demonstrated that this is the rare case in which discovery is necessary in a special action Plaintiff Discovery Practice U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act
  “While the statute permits courts to order an index from a public body other than an agency in appropriate circumstances, such relief is unnecessary here because Plaintiff has failed to present any evidence that responsive records were discovered but improperly withheld. ## CONCLUSION Plaintiff has not demonstrated that this is the rare case in which discovery is necessary in a special action.”
• discovery Discovery Practice concept → be in → a special action U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act
  “While the statute permits courts to order an index from a public body other than an agency in appropriate circumstances, such relief is unnecessary here because Plaintiff has failed to present any evidence that responsive records were discovered but improperly withheld. ## CONCLUSION Plaintiff has not demonstrated that this is the rare case in which discovery is necessary in a special action.”
• His motion Motion to Pay concept → seek requested → intrusive examination of internal processes
  “His motion is grounded in speculation, rather than evidence, seeks intrusive examination of internal processes, and would undermine the expedited framework governing special actions. ”
• the City the City individual City of Birth concept → request For requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested → these reasons
  “For these reasons, the City respectfully requests that the Court deny Plaintiff's Motion for Limited Discovery and Index. ”
• Discovery Discovery Practice concept → disfavor in → special actions U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act
  “Discovery is strongly disfavored in special actions.”
• discovery Discovery Practice concept → permit in approved → exceedingly rare instances where it is absolutely necessary for the resolution of the disputed issues
  “Accordingly, discovery is permitted only in exceedingly rare instances where it is absolutely necessary for the resolution of the disputed issues.”
• His motion Motion to Pay concept → premise on → concrete evidence of inadequate search or unlawful withholding Evidence Search Unlawful Wage Withholding Claim
  “His motion is premised not on concrete evidence of inadequate search or unlawful withholding, but on speculation and inference.”
• requests → flag as Communicate (in firm) → high profile
  “That twenty months elapsed before the City provided Plaintiff with the responsive records, and that the Plaintiff's name was included on an emailed list of individuals and topics for which requests should be flagged as high profile, does not warrant the Court taking the rare step of ordering discovery.”
• This concept → discuss in → LKQ Corp v. Kia Motors Am . , Inc. , where the court explained : LKQ Corp v. Court Forum Discovery Practice
  “This concept was discussed in LKQ Corp v. Kia Motors Am., Inc. , where the court explained: Discovery production is akin to an honor system.”
• Plaintiff 's Asserted Need for Information Plaintiff concept Information Industry concept → provide Through Communicate → Less Intrusive Means
  “Plaintiff's Asserted Need for Information Can Be Provided Through Less Intrusive Means. ”
• His motion Motion to Pay concept → ground in → speculation
  “His motion is grounded in speculation, rather than evidence, seeks intrusive examination of internal processes, and would undermine the expedited framework governing special actions. ”
• Plaintiff Plaintiff concept → be with → which
  “As reflected in the City's standard communications to Plaintiff acknowledging his requests-communications with which Plaintiff is undoubtedly familiar, as he has filed 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 a total of twenty-six public records requests with the City since July of 2023-requests are processed in accordance with A.R.S. § 39-121 et seq.”
• This new employee Employee concept → bring to → four
  “This new employee brings the headcount of the Public Records Division to four.”
• she → receive On → the Public Records Coordinator 's first day Public Records Act Claim
  “On the Public Records Coordinator's first day, she received an emailed list of requesters and topics to flag to management.”
• he → fail for → Limited Discovery and Index Limited Discovery Discovery Practice
  “for Limited Discovery and Index, at 4], he fails to inform this Court that after he filed this matter, the City worked cooperatively with his counsel to conduct an additional search for records.”
• that → go beyond → Plaintiff 's initial public records requests Plaintiff Request Public Records Act Claim
  “In fact, the City's attorneys cooperated in good faith with Plaintiff's counsel to make reasonable efforts to locate the records Plaintiff sought by formulating agreed-upon search terms that went well beyond Plaintiff's initial public records requests.”
• It → require → the preservation of records beyond approved retention schedules , or the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 undertaking of limitless investigative efforts to satisfy speculation that additional documents might exist Retention Schedule Schedules and Statements Extension Motion
  “It does not require the creation of new records, the preservation of records beyond approved retention schedules, or the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 undertaking of limitless investigative efforts to satisfy speculation that additional documents might exist.”
• the court in an original special action Court Forum concept U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act concept → ground on → which
  “'Unless an appropriate showing is made on which the court in an original special action can ground its exercise of discretion to issue special orders concerning discovery, the parties are generally not entitled to discovery.'”
• The trial court Trial Court Practice concept Court Forum concept → rule at → 198
  “at 198 ('The trial court, after a hearing, ruled that some of the information had already been furnished to the Recipients and that the remainder of the information sought was not relevant or of sufficient evidentiary value to warrant an order compelling discovery.').”
• discovery Discovery Practice concept → be in → which
  “Plaintiff's reliance on a February 28, 2022, email referencing text messages likewise falls short of demonstrating that this is the rare case in which discovery is necessary.”
• e → reflect concerning → the requisite substantial nexus Government Relations
  “[s]ome e-mails will relate solely to personal matters and will not, therefore, reflect the requisite substantial nexus with government activities.'”
• e → relate to concerning → personal matters
  “[s]ome e-mails will relate solely to personal matters and will not, therefore, reflect the requisite substantial nexus with government activities.'”
• that → constitute applies → public records Public Records Act Claim
  “Here, the February 28, 2022 email leaves unanswered the question of whether Councilmember Pastor sent or received texts that constitute public records, as opposed to messages that were personal in nature.”
• Plaintiff 's assertions Plaintiff concept → be Without → more
  “Without more, Plaintiff's assertions are too attenuated to justify the need for discovery. ”
• that → be within Manage data/files → their client 's possession , custody , and control Legal Services Buyer Possession of a Controlled Substance
  “We trust that attorneys uphold their professional obligations and responsibilities by following the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure to produce relevant, nonprivileged information, after a reasonable inquiry, that is within their client's possession, custody, and control.”
• they → need into → the collection , review , and processing methodology of their opponent Debt Collection Practice
  “They may request more information after an initial disclosure or argue about objections, but generally they do not need a deep dive into the collection, review, and processing methodology of their opponent.”
• They → request requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested → more information Information Industry
  “They may request more information after an initial disclosure or argue about objections, but generally they do not need a deep dive into the collection, review, and processing methodology of their opponent.”
• They → request after requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested requested → an initial disclosure Disclosure Statement
  “They may request more information after an initial disclosure or argue about objections, but generally they do not need a deep dive into the collection, review, and processing methodology of their opponent.”
• it → be → the bedrock of modern discovery practice Discovery Practice
  “Trust in an adversarial process appears contradictory at first, but it is the bedrock of modern discovery practice and has worked well for decades. ## 345 F.R.D. 152, 156 (N.D. Ill. 2023). ”
• it → be → # # 345 F.R.D. 152 , 156 ( N.D. Ill. 2023 ) 345 F.R.D. 152 N.D. Ill. Illinois Supreme Court
  “Trust in an adversarial process appears contradictory at first, but it is the bedrock of modern discovery practice and has worked well for decades. ## 345 F.R.D. 152, 156 (N.D. Ill. 2023). ”
• Trust in an adversarial process Trust concept Contentious concept → appear → contradictory at first
  “Trust in an adversarial process appears contradictory at first, but it is the bedrock of modern discovery practice and has worked well for decades. ## 345 F.R.D. 152, 156 (N.D. Ill. 2023). ”
• which → be → a notoriously burdensome discovery tool Discovery Practice Discovery Motion Practice
  “Instead, he's opted for a 30(b)(6) deposition, which is a notoriously burdensome discovery tool.”
• that → span across → multiple Public Records requests Request Public Records Act Claim
  “Despite his purported 'evidence' of nonresponsiveness being limited to text messages sent to Councilmember Pastor, Plaintiff is requesting to depose a representative of the City on fifteen sweeping categories that span across multiple Public Records requests. ”
• they → apply to applies → the City , a large , complex organization with more than 14,000 employees and 41 departments the City City of Birth Entity
  “1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Notably, these are just two of the fifteen requests, and they would apply universally to the City, a large, complex organization with more than 14,000 employees and 41 departments. ”
• that → provide Communicate → reasonable detail of the scope of the search Search
  “Indeed, this was mentioned as the preferred method in Plaintiff's own legal authority: '[T]he agency may rely on affidavits or declarations that provide reasonable detail of the scope of the search.'”
• A.R.S. § § individual A.R.S. individual → define as → 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 any board , commission , department , officer or other administrative unit of this state Commission
  “A.R.S. § 41-1001(1) defines 'agency' as: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 any board, commission, department, officer or other administrative unit of this state, including the agency head and one or more members of the agency head or agency employees or other persons directly or indirectly purporting to act on behalf or under the authority of the agency head, whether created under the Constitution of Arizona or by enactment of the legislature.”
• discovery Discovery Practice concept → be in → which
  “While the statute permits courts to order an index from a public body other than an agency in appropriate circumstances, such relief is unnecessary here because Plaintiff has failed to present any evidence that responsive records were discovered but improperly withheld. ## CONCLUSION Plaintiff has not demonstrated that this is the rare case in which discovery is necessary in a special action.”
• Which → permit in approved → Special Actions U.S. Special Court under the Regional Rail Reorganization Act
  “## I. Discovery-Which Is Rarely Permitted in Special Actions-Is Not Justified Here Because It Is Not Necessary. ”
• requests → flag for Communicate (in firm) → which
  “That twenty months elapsed before the City provided Plaintiff with the responsive records, and that the Plaintiff's name was included on an emailed list of individuals and topics for which requests should be flagged as high profile, does not warrant the Court taking the rare step of ordering discovery.”
• he → opt for → a 30(b)(6 ) deposition , which is a notoriously burdensome discovery tool Deposition Discovery Practice Discovery Motion Practice
  “Instead, he's opted for a 30(b)(6) deposition, which is a notoriously burdensome discovery tool.”
• this → mention as → the preferred method in Plaintiff 's own legal authority Plaintiff Authority
  “Indeed, this was mentioned as the preferred method in Plaintiff's own legal authority: '[T]he agency may rely on affidavits or declarations that provide reasonable detail of the scope of the search.'”

Properties (183)

Words in the document that map to FOLIO predicate concepts (e.g. "dispute" → opposed, "alleges" → claim). Each row shows the text as it appears in the document, the FOLIO concept it resolves to, and the source pass that matched it.